Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
The American Gem Registry. is Colorado's premier complete service, gemological laboratory and jewelry appraisal service. We support both sellers and buyers of diamonds, gemstones and jewelry by providing independent, accurate and USEFUL information. Diamond and jewelry appraisals and consulting are all we do.
Reviews (24)
Write a Review
Debbie Aragon
Jun 11, 2022
Neil is outstanding- I had a number of pieces that I had no idea about value - Neil was very personable, conscientious, knowledgeable, honest, and thorough - I would highly recommend Neil and American Gem Registry with the highest confidence and without hesitation! Deb
Balin Yurglich
May 22, 2022
Neil is very professional and an expert. He is very efficient and thorough. We definitely recommend him.
Joseph Karas
Dec 03, 2021
Quick response, easy appointment scheduling, and an enjoyable 45 minute insurance appraisal of diamond ring that was inherited. Nice guy who is a total pro.
Brian Bradley
Oct 12, 2021
My experience with Neil was great. Very knowledgeable and helped me understand diamonds/appraisal process more fully. Helped me check that diamond I bought online was real, was the specs suggested, and priced appropriately. Would recommend him to anyone trying to get a diamond or other types of gems appraised. Thank you Neil!
Mike VanWyngarden
Sep 28, 2021
Did a great job with a family heirloom band and was very kind and knowledgeable!
Susan Monahan
May 15, 2021
It was a very easy and smooth process. Neil Was knowledgeable and friendly. I definitely would utilize his services again.
Brandon Davis
Jun 04, 2020
If you are in need of a 100% honest professional opinion, regarding seemingly any topic regarding diamonds/diamond jewelry, Neil is the man!
Casey I.
Dec 17, 2019
Neal was outstanding. I had a box of inherited jewelry and he went through it, gave me some great valuations and input, all for a very fair price.
Andrew S.
Sep 06, 2019
Excellent service, professional, and great conversation. Would recommend. Neil is great, very experienced and gave me great advice about how to go forward with my engagement and options for what can be done with the stone. Highly recommended.
Megan F.
Jul 26, 2019
Five stars is not enough! Neil is one of the most honest businessmen I have EVER had the pleasure of doing business with. I needed a few items appraised before selling them and I had no clue of their value. Neil gave me his professional opinion on which pieces would be worth the appraisal and which would not because their value was less than an appraisal would cost.

If you are looking for the best in HONESTY and QUALITY work look no further than Neil Beaty at the American Gem Registry. I will definitely return for future appraisal needs! Thank you Neil!
Caitlin Emery
Jun 16, 2018
Neil is such a great guy. He not only did a great job on the appraisal, but he also explained everything and told us what the insurance company would need etc. Additionally he gave us so much information about diamonds and ours specifically. It was a wonderful experience and I would utilize his services in the future!
Calli N.
Jan 10, 2018
I recently had my engagement ring appriased by Neil, he is extremely professional and did the appraisal while I waited - no dropping off the ring and having to pick it up at a later date! Would highly recommend his services. Thanks, Neil!
Layla R.
Mar 31, 2017
I was referred to Neil Beaty through a consumer advocacy website. I was having my engagement diamond reset into a new setting a few years ago. The jeweler was in NY, I am in CA and Neil was in Colorado. I was very nervous and wanted Neil to be my 'middle man'. He unset my stone and appraised it unset. Then sent the stone to the designer who was creating the setting.

After the stone was reset, it was sent to Neil again for him to appraise the piece now set. When I lost my ring late last year Neil's bullet proof appraisal is what helped me negotiate with my insurance policy. Because it was do so detailed, and because of his reputation in the industry the insurance company knew that they had to deal with me fairly.

If I hadn't had such an incredibly detailed appraisal, they would have replaced my ring with any old thing that was the same shape and the same basic design00 but in no way the same quality. And that would have been a huge loss financially.
Scott C.
Dec 14, 2016
Great experience. Extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Professional location and appraiser. very satisfied with my experience. Wouldn't go anywhere else!
Alexander Stewart
Sep 21, 2016
Most helpful. He was open and honest about my past purchase of gems. He did an appraisal and saved me a fair amount of change through his honesty. It wasn't the news I wanted, but he didn't string me along. Very pleased with my visit.
Ryan Ellis
Mar 04, 2016
Neil did a fantastic appraisal for an affordable price. His jewelry appraisal services are very thorough and he does it all while you wait. This saves time and ensures your engagement ring or jewelry item is safe. Highly recommended.
Kali G.
Jul 14, 2015
Neil was extremely knowledgeable and honest. Overall a great experience, we learned a lot about the history and processes behind the pieces we brought in. We would definitely recommend him to anyone looking for an appraisal of their jewelry. However, plan on spending a little time doing it, this is not a quick 15 min stop in the mall.
Katie H.
Apr 22, 2015
Today was my first experience having jewlery appraised. Neil was so awesome and explained everything very clearly and made me feel very comfortable with his fair value of my rings. I highly recommend Neil! Free parking, convenient location off of I-25, safe/secure building, and friendly conversation made my jewlery appraisal easy and fun!
Sheri Allen
Apr 01, 2015
Neil is a globally known appraiser. He is a very knowledgeable gemologist who really cares about his clients. He takes the time to answer all the questions you might have. He is a professional witness and helps with business and estate valuations. His easy manor and professionalism are hard to beat. Need some help? Give him a call. He is the best!
Sean M.
Feb 14, 2015
I was hesitant about finding an expert to appraise an engagement ring I purchased and needed insured. If you are in need of getting a diamond appraised, Neil is the guy to see. His location is conveniently located in the Denver Merchandise Mart. Neil was professional, informative and did it all right in front of me. He gave me a mini lesson on the stone, and the diamond details "diamond people" would want to know. He was friendly through the whole process. At the end, he conveniently emailed all the information to my account and even sent information to the insurance company.
Thomas C.
May 16, 2014
Neil is fantastic! Went in this morning to get a diamond "recertified" and it was a really great experience. He was capable of the GIA certs, but in my case it wasnt necessary. He has quite the set up in his shop and i was very impressed with his high degree of professionalism throughout the process I was able to ask him a multitude of questions, and was even able to ask him questions about the new setting.

Since he has been in the jewellry business for about 20 years he knows quite a bit. He explained prices on the setting I was considering and what to expect from local jewellers. He wouldnt make endorsements because he works with most reputable jewellers in denver. I thought that that spoke well to his integrity. The experience lasted about 40 minutes for my single diamond and wasn't painful or boring!
Pburar
Dec 27, 2013
Neil is an astonishing expert, and likely the most experienced appraiser in the entire state, if not the entire country. From the moment I walked in, Neil spent more than enough time answering my questions, and gave me a history on differences in diamond cut and grading from different labs that was absolutely fascinating. I never, during the entire visit, did I feel rushed.

It is evident from Neil's enthusiasm that he takes a lot of pride in what he does, and he passes that on to the consumer. If you are looking to get a diamond appraised in the Denver Metro area, I would HIGHLY recommend you visit with Neil over anyone else. I felt VERY confident that my appraisal was done correctly, and, he seamlessly sent my information over to Perfect Circle Insurance so that my request for coverage was expedited. Please, do yourself and your jewelry a favor, and pay Neil a visit. I promise you won't regret this decision.
Matt Klouda
Jan 14, 2013
Absolutely great experience and service. Right from the get go Neil will make you feel comfortable and right at home. No matter the size of the gem, or the reason it is well worth it to sit down with him and get an understanding of what you have in your possession. If I ever have another gem need, I will be certain to go see him again.
Stephanie S.
Nov 02, 2012
I went to Neil today for a ring appraisal after I got a bad feeling from my first (unprofessional) appraiser. It was an appraisal for engagement ring bought online. Neil was so nice, helpful, and professional. I watched the entire appraisal and Neil let me ask 1 million questions and took the time to educate me, which I really appreciated! The report was complete and explained clearly. Thank you Neil!