Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Delmonte-Smelson Jewelers Since 1972, the Delmonte-Smelson name has been synonymous with fine jewelry, elegance, and style. Our expert jewelers pride themselves in being highly educated in all aspects of the jewelry industry so that we can make your visit both pleasurable and easy. From designer jewelry and watches to one-of-a-kind custom-made jewelry, we at Delmonte-Smelson Jewelers want all of the pieces passed from our hands to yours to be adored for years to come!

Delmonte-Smelson Fine Jewelers is committed to your satisfaction.
Follow us
Services
Just about everyone has an outdated pendant or bracelet, a ring with a missing stone, an earring without a mate, coins from an abandoned collection, silverware you'll never use again, or a gold watch you inherited but always hated. It may be unloved, unwanted, and unused, but it's not without value.
Gold and other precious metals are selling at or near all-time record high prices - the highest in over 25 years. Now is the perfect time to turn your old jewelry into new custom jewelry or cash to finance a night on the town, a special vacation, or the kids' education. Delmonte-Smelson, conveniently located across from the Nassau Coliseum in Rexcorp Plaza, has provided Long Islanders with fine jewelry and sound advice since 1971.
For more than 45 years, the Delmonte-Smelson name has been synonymous with fine jewelry, elegance, and style. We offer a broad selection, including designer jewelry and watches from classic to contemporary, including from KC Designs, Sophia D., Unique Settings, Gem Trends and Citizen.
You can browse Gem Trends' products, which include anklets, bangles, bracelets, charms, cufflinks, earrings, necklaces, pins, and rings, on their older gated website, which requires registration, or on their actively maintained Instagram page.
Reviews (14)
Write a Review
Jessica C. Almendares
Feb 08, 2022
I live out of state & dealt with Jonathan by phone & email. He was very professional, quick to respond to emails and always available to speak to whenever I called for him. Everything was handled in a timely manner. This is especially important when dealing with pieces of jewelry that have sentimental value. I would recommend Delmonte-Smelson and if needed, do business again with them in the future! Thank you!
Nicky Morreale
May 01, 2021
I was introduced to John by a mutual friend and let me say I'm sure glad I was! He went above and beyond for me when creating my fiance's engagement ring. From picking the stone, to designing the setting, production and delivery John was there every step of the way. Even had to get it sized bc I didn't know her actual finger size and he was so accommodating. He made this process seamless, and pleasurable! I am a client for life. Thank you again!
William J. Stevens V.
Mar 24, 2021
The folks at Delmonte-Smelson have become dear friends through these challenging pandemic times. Looking back to October 2019 when I went in to buy my now wife an engagement ring, I was met with personalized, concierge-like care and attention. I had a great interaction with one of the employees Stephanie who helped me narrow down what style I was looking for, and then a one-on-one meeting with the owner Phil for a full education on diamond clarity, color, and pricepoint to find the absolute perfect stone for my soon to be-betrothed.

She said yes, and we were off to planning a wedding! Despite all the craziness we've faced as a community, unknown hardships set unto small businesses as well, the Delmonte-Smelson team managed to come through in the midst of it all. Phil again helped find the perfect band for my wife, and (without my knowledge) the exact ring I wanted, too! They even custom ordered and rush delivered it to help us out.

My wife and I cannot highly recommend these folks enough. The integrity with which they operate is outstanding. It can be intimidating going in to a jeweler knowing nothing of the industry, but I was met with warmth that put me at ease. I don't see myself going anywhere else for future anniversaries or family gifts.
John D.
Jan 26, 2021
Phil and his team are amazing. I purchased a ring back in January and it was quick, easy and beautiful. I showed them a picture of what I was envisioning and they turned it into a reality. They're so talented, especially Phil. My fiancee tells me regularly how much she loves her ring. Fellas, this is the place to go for a beautiful, unique, custom piece.
Lynne Murray
Nov 26, 2019
Thank you to Phil and his staff for the beautiful work designing and creating my new ring! I love the halo setting and have received many compliments.
Meg M.
Apr 23, 2019
I'm a returning customer and want to share my raving review. Both Phil and Jon are incredibly professional, personable and wonderful to work with. There are countless beautiful pieces displayed in the showroom and they also offer expert guidance to create custom pieces. They turned my vision into a beautiful reality! Hands down, I recommend Delmonte-Smelson for anyone looking for quality jewelry.
Joshua Katz
Nov 12, 2018
Customer service is king at Delmonte-Smelson Jewelers. Made an appointment before coming in and told them what we were looking for. When we arrived they brought out a ton of options, all of them at incredibly reasonable prices. Brought out a more expensive chain but didn't try to push us into buying it. Let us make the best decision and leave with a great item for a great price. Phil is extremely friendly and will treat you like you are part of his family. Would definitely recommend them to all of my friends.
Arianna Kaufman
May 06, 2018
THIS PLACE IS INCREDIBLE! I have been dreaming about my engagement ring since I was a little girl and this jeweler far surpassed my wildest dreams of what my engagement ring would look like. They were patient, and spent so much time making sure that I was happy with my ring. I would highly recommend this place to everyone! Thank you for the most beautiful ring ever!
April G.
Apr 11, 2018
Found this hidden gem by chance. Located in the EAB plaza on Hempstead Turnpike. The owner Phil is truly professional, honest and patient. He designed an absolutely stunning engagement ring and wedding band for me! Would high recommend for anyone shopping for diamonds or any other beautiful Jewlery.
Harlee Damiani
Dec 23, 2017
I had my engagement ring created here. A few years later had very sentimental wedding bands created from jewelry from my deceased mother. I wouldnt trust any other jeweler with valuables with such sentiment! I'd give 100 stars if I could! Love love love Delmonte-Smelson!
Steven Ostrower
Jul 30, 2017
I highly recommend Delmonte-Smelson. I recently purchased an upgraded engagement ring. Customer service was top notch. I have the utmost trust and confidence that Delmonte-Smelson delivered the highest quality product at the fairest price. Total value was beyond expectations.
Joe Pawluk
Jun 03, 2017
I got my fiancee's custom made engagement ring at Delmonte-Smelson and I couldn't be happier. They took a picture and made it into reality. Mike and his team were great, giving me a real education about what I was purchasing, and working with my ideas and budget. Great experience overall.
Raymond Gluchowski
May 20, 2016
Well, my experience with the store has not been a good one. I am quite upset with there estimates and appraisals of diamonds. I purchased a GIA certified diamond from this store around 1997 for almost $4,000.00. To my surprise Mr. Smelson advised me today, he would not repurchase the diamond and he gave it an estimated value of several hundred dollars.

I was not expecting to make money on my original purchase. I only hoped he would give me a fair price for an item he originally sold to me. In my opinion, the diamond should have maintained some value. I find it hard to believe he would not stand by his work and original judgment.
Danielle G.
Dec 23, 2013
I've came here several times to remove links off of some new watches & also buy new watches at this jeweler, & every time I've came to do so they've treated me with the best customer service. There prices are extremely easy on your wallet & they're location is also very convenient. The diamond rings & necklaces they have on display are also beautiful with custom designs & great prices. Thanks DMJ!