Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Coffrin Jewelers started in Sarasota in 1980 as the dream of Terry Coffrin. He grew his business as a jewelry designer and master watchmaker. His first location was in Coral Cove Mall on South Tamiami Trail. In 1980 Terry and his wife, Belinda, relocated to their current location in Sarasota's historic Southside Village.

Coffrin Jewelers has maintained the reputation for excellent jewelry and watch repair as well custom jewelry design. At "The Shoppe Worth Discovering, " we are here to help you celebrate the special moments in your life by helping you to satisfy your jewelry needs.
Follow us
Services
At Coffrin Jewelers, we strive to offer the best in appraisal and gemstone analysis services available. Appraisals are most commonly requested for insurance, estate purposes, or simply for peace of mind. On occasion, appraisals are requested for various other purposes; such as barter, divorce or to determine the actual cash value.
Free personal consultation with our designer to discuss what you want made, create a sketch, and determine how to fit it in your budget. Next our designer takes your ideas to the computer. This is when the sketch will really start to take shape. Here he will create a digital render of your idea to better show you what your final piece will look like.
Reviews (26)
Write a Review
Monty Ghosh
Jun 09, 2022
Fabulous folks - Jason is awesome and very professional- it felt like home when I was inquiring.
Bruce S.
Mar 16, 2022
I needed a new watch band. The only one they had was $155. You try to shop locally but with service like this you are forced to go online. Amazon Leather watch band 19.99. Plus tools to change the band.
Alexis Osborn
Feb 08, 2022
Went in looking for a rose gold wedding band. They had a beautiful selection to chose from. The jeweler understood what I was looking for and made the process easy. I ended up finding my ring at a different place, but I would have ordered here if I hadn't.
Anna L.
Feb 03, 2022
I'm sorry to say I am very skeptical about this place and after my experience. I will not go back and also caution others wanting to do business here. I brought in a small watch, which was very old, for a battery replacement. While the battery was changed and returned to me, it still did not work. I left it there to be checked out and found that for it to be fixed, it needed to be "cleaned out" which would cost $115.

I felt something off so I brought it to another location for a second opinion. The watch company in UTC mall changed out the complete watch kit for only $69. I wonder how much more Coffrin would have charged to replace the kit. They did not even offer that option. For watch repair, I suggest going elsewhere.
Wendy Ross
Jan 07, 2022
If there was a way to do a 10 star review, I would! Chase and Joe helped me and their patience and knowledge and obvious enjoyment and passion in what they do every day makes the entire experience so great. You can trust Coffrin Jewelers to do a great job! They are attentive and there is no high pressure. No job is too small and they take great pride in doing the job right. Thank you Coffrin Jewelers!
Adam Palermo
Dec 17, 2021
When you don't matter, they don't care! When you go in for a consultation for a wedding ring and you check in and months later they haven't produced anything.don't waste your money! Because they don't actually care about the customer!
Madeline W.
Apr 14, 2021
I brought my rose gold engagement ring here to be resized from a 7 to a 5 1/2. I had a very short window and Coffrin Jewelers worked with me to complete my ring in less than 48 hours. The price was very reasonable and the timeline was much shorter compared to other places I got a quote from in the area. I definitely recommend them for repairs! Pics are before and after.
Molly McAllister
Mar 28, 2021
When I went into the shop that had amazing service. They helped me find the perfect gift for my mothers birthday and she loves it. Highly recommend going here for gifts or yourself!
Pierina Chica
Mar 12, 2021
Had a broken chain which they helped me fix. Reasonable price and nice staff
Haylee Fisher
Jan 25, 2021
Love this place! They helped me find the perfect gift for my moms birthday! They really have amazing earrings and go here especially if you like rose gold they have tons of rose gold jewelry!
Fynn B.
Dec 10, 2020
Went in to view rings on a whim and was delighted to be helped by chase. He was very professional and genuine. Most places just try to sell stuff but this place actually cares that you are getting what you want/need. If you want beautiful jewelry, great service, and a clean conscience of going local- this is the place! Can't wait to go in and design a ring!
Morgan Johnson
Nov 09, 2020
The staff are the best people I have had a chance to deal with. They always try to accommodate your wishes, while also being truthful. They also have a great selection of jewelry!
Damaris Oliveira
Nov 05, 2020
The staff here is really kind and helpful! Taylor helped me pick out the perfect bracelet for my boyfriend for our anniversary. I will definitely be returning if I ever need to buy a gift for anyone or to pick out something for myself!
Cathy S.
Jun 11, 2020
This jewelry store is my go-to place for birthday gifts, for repairs and for just in-case-I-find-something. I love this store and Belinda's knowledge. I have a favorite ring that I wear from time to time which Belinda created for me. Every time I wear it it makes me smile. My parents loved this store too. It's been around forever and that's a good thing.
Kathryn H. Jtineant
Mar 10, 2020
Felt very confident about the service provided. Estimate was provided and I was kept informed of details of my watch repair. Done promptly, efficiently and with polite service, can't ask for more! Will definitely return, saw lots of things on display that caught my eye, especially that cool Octopus cuff!
Lynne S.
Feb 17, 2020
Worst service ever, and it was the owner, Belinda Coffrin who was my salesperson. I brought in an Ebel watch for the addition of a link and a "SpaCleaning". They had it well over 6 weeks and never got around to working on it. I called every few days and was often told Belinda was out. When I did reach her she would often tell me jeweler wasn't in. I continually asked her to check on status and call me back which she never did. I finally went back thoroughly disgusted and retrieved it in it's original condition.
Christine Morris Brown
Dec 05, 2019
Love supporting locally owned stores with amazing customer service~!
Matthew Lewis
Jul 19, 2019
The most amazing professionals I've ever met! Their knowledge, artistry, honesty and ability to deliver is epic. My wife and I thank you for giving us the pieces of art that we wear and will till the end!
Kenneth LeRoy Merritt
Mar 25, 2019
Coffrin Jewelers offers some of the most courteous and professional customer service anyone could ever ask for. I've personally been working with them for around five years and they've always surpassed my expectations. Thank you all, Kenny Merritt
Gabriela Abaroa
Jan 29, 2019
They are fantastic! Very friendly and welcoming. I picked the wrong resize for engagement ring( great grandmas, family heirloom) and they fixed it on the spot no hassle. Couldn't be any happier!
Tomo Marjanovic
Nov 30, 2018
Beautiful pieces that really catch the eye! Every diamond is high quality and every piece is unique.
Tracy R.
Sep 25, 2018
You guys have really unique one of a kind pieces can't wait till I can purchase one. I have watched as Jason has posted beautiful rings that he has made. The earring that are being given away what are they being made of they are starfish and what stone? I would love to be the winner.
Natasha Blanke-Eldridge
Sep 22, 2018
Great experience, professional, courteous and beautiful pieces.love my wedding band and ring! Definitely recommend this business!
Kelli G.
Mar 25, 2016
Love them. My watch stopped and a band came loose. I was wary to bring my time piece to businesses along the trail who advertised Rolex servicing for $2-$300 or anyone for that matter. However, I happened upon them one day after grabbing a fresh squeezed OJ next door. Their professional approach, prestige and care they showed won me over and I'm so pleased.

My 2005 timepiece is brand new and they happily cleaned my rings to perfection. The servicing of my watch wasn't cheap, but you get what you pay for! Thank you, Donna, for your stellar customer service. This is the only place I will go to purchase or have my jewelry serviced.
Elisabeth W.
Feb 26, 2016
The people at Coffrin are wonderful. My mother needed to have her rings cleaned and sized. She is elderly and suffers from dementia and I was concerned about her losing her rings or the possibility that they could be stolen from her at her care facility. I wanted to preserve my mother's property and her sense that her possessions are still hers, even if she is no longer able to make decisions about them, but I also wanted to be sure that her rings are safe.

It was a difficult and emotionally charged situation. I went to Coffrin and they were very understanding. They have helped others with my dilemma, as was clear from their knowledge and sensitivity. They made good, practical suggestions. They also verified that I am who I say I am and that I am my mother's daughter, all in a professional and sensitive way.

They helped to protect my mother's interests and helped me do the same. When I brought my mother into the store, the staff were attentive and kind. They patiently answered her repeated questions and treated her with dignity. I am so grateful to them for their help. Thank you, Coffrin Jewelers.
Gary H.
Mar 15, 2013
Not a big fan of jewelry stores but they have the best selection of Reactor watches in town. Reactor such a good watch, s specifically for diving but great for everyday wear. The five stars represents the helpfulness I receive from the staff whenever I'm in there.