Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
I am Milan Petrovic, owner and experienced Master Jeweler of Milan's Jewelry in Sarasota, Florida. I take pride in building relationships with clients based on exceptional, personalized service. I can custom tailor to your jewelry needs. Whatever your jewelry needs may be; jewelry repair, redesigning an heirloom piece, or picking out the engagement ring for the love of your life, I take pride in providing a positive and memorable experience. What makes Milan's Jewelry so special is that we are a small business.
Follow us
Services
Bring your damaged jewelry to Milan- as a master jeweler, he puts nothing but the highest regard for care and perfection into its repair. We offer remounting services, so bring in any broken, outdated, or unused jewelry and have a custom piece created. We can take your old gemstones and remount them into a new, custom-designed piece.
At Milans Jewelry, our mission is to help you bring your engagement ring vision to life. The perfect custom engagement ring is just a few clicks away. We have everything you need to design an engagement ring that is as unique as the person who will be wearing it. Explore the incredible build your own engagement ring options for your ideal engagement ring.
At Milan's Jewelry, we offer one of the best selection of engagement rings in Sarasota, FL and the surrounding areas. Are you looking for an engagement ring that is classic, modern, or dazzlingly unique? Through our variety of engagement ring settings, you're sure to find one that will bring your style to perfection.
Our Four C's of Diamonds guide can help you decide on the most important factors when shopping for a diamond. The word carat derives from the word carob, a Mediterranean seed, which has an extremely consistent weight for measuring. The greater the carat weight, the rarer, and more valuable the diamond becomes.
Reviews (9)
Write a Review
Corinne Hatley
Jun 11, 2022
A true professional gives the client what they need, not just what they ask for. That's what you can expect at Milan's Jewelry. My husband proposed to me with his grandmother's ring from 1951. We brought it into Milan to have it sized to my finger, and Milan brought some issues to our attention. Since she never took it off her finger, it had some serious signs of wear that I hadn't even noticed before Milan pointed them out.

The prongs holding the diamond were almost completely flat and I was at risk of losing the stone. The back of the ring was also so thin from years of wear that it could have snapped at any time. Milan built up the prongs, reinforced the back, sized the band perfectly, and cleaned the ring. It looked brand new! We were so impressed with the quality and professionalism that we returned to Milan for our wedding bands.

We ordered a simple band for my husband and a custom shadow band to match my engagement ring. Again, Milan exceeded our expectations. We won't go to any other jeweler and we can't recommend Milan's Jewelry enough!
Dominic Fantauzzo
Jun 08, 2022
We did a custom design and Milan delivered exactly what we wanted at a reasonable price. We stopped at several local jewelry stores before choosing Milan's. No one could deliver the same quality at an affordable price.
Connie Garrett
Apr 25, 2022
When my previous jeweler retired, he referred me to Milan to have my diamond palm tree repaired and I was so pleased with the results that I trusted him again to replace a diamond I had lost out of my wedding band due to broken prongs. Not only did he replace the diamond, he replaced all of the prongs so I wouldn't lose another diamond. I picked up my ring and was in awe of its appearance, as sparkly and shiny as it was first placed on my finger 38 years ago. I highly recommend Milan's Jewelry at 1666 Main St Sarasota, Fl 34236 for all of your jewelry needs.
Katy Malone
Mar 31, 2022
Milan is the nicest jeweler in Sarasota hands down. If you know what you want, he can accommodate you. If you need ideas, then he is your guy for wedding rings or wanting to buy gems and make something.fabulous for you.
Brandon Ziegler
Dec 13, 2021
Wow. Great experience. I went through Facebook trying to find an actual jeweler. This was the only place I could find where they had a jeweler on site. The owner sits at the counter and is the guy that does the work. The price for putting a new setting and new diamond on my ring was fair and I agreed. Afterwards he saw my license said I'm I veteran and gave me a discount. The ring was done in was less time than I expected. Satisfied is an understatement.
Erica Hall
Dec 10, 2021
Could not recommend Milan and his team more! He is so kind and you can tell actually cares about what he does. I got a new diamond set in my original engagement band and I am absolutely in love! He did a wonderful job with such a quick turnaround! Will definitely be back! Thank you so much Milan!
Jared DeVirgilis
Sep 06, 2021
Milan did an amazing job customizing my fiancee's engagement ring. I was so impressed by his attention to detail. We recently went back to have him make the wedding band as well. From the beginning, he has been honest, really great and easy to work with, and made the whole process very pleasant. Plus, he's just a really nice guy. I have nothing but good things to say about Milan and highly recommend his services.
Jordan Benedict
May 28, 2021
Milan transformed my Mom Mom's ring into my engagement ring that's even more stunning than I could've imagined. He did a great job restoring the piece while making it more current and my style. I love that it has sentimental value as a family heirloom while also being very me. Milan worked really well with my fiance making the ring to make it a surprise for me.

The ring also had a quick turnaround time (which helped my fiance with surprising me). We felt very comfortable with him, which was such a relief as this was a family piece. Highly recommend!
Casandra McClean
Jan 09, 2021
Wonderful customer service all around! I took and antique diamond and sapphire ring to them to turn it into a necklace. Not only did they know exactly how to handle it with care, they were able to have the project finished quickly and reasonably. The job itself was not an expensive one but they didn't seem to matter. They still gave me excellent customer service and didn't try to sell me on things I didn't want/need.

Other jewelers in Sarasota have turned me away or tried to scam me because they couldn't be bothered with a such a small project. I will be going back to Milan's for my future jewelry needs and recommending them to my friends and family! And bonus, their shop dog is beautiful and so friendly!