Forsythe Jewelers has been quietly delivering the best jewelry in the Rochester area since 1927. Three generations of the Forsythe family have been trusted in diamonds, colored gemstone custom designs and repairs. Accredited by the AGS, American Gem Society, Forsythe provides a well equipped gem lab and a certified gemologist on site to show you how to compare diamonds for cut, color and clarity.
Follow us
Services
Appointments are available for consultations, cleaning, shopping and repairs. Or stop by for an impromptu visit, walk-ins are always welcome. Want to put a face to the name? Meet our trusted staff at Forsythe Jewelers. Our friendly and qualified staff is here to help you achieve any of your fine jewelry needs. We look forward to serving you soon!
A jewelry appraisal is an important way to protect your investment in your jewelry pieces, and you won't find more accurate assessments than at Forsythe Jewelers. Whether you need an appraisal for insurance purposes or to set a dollar value to your unique pieces, we can ensure your jewelry is assessed with the utmost accuracy and care.
As we age, our bodies change, and jewelry that once felt comfortable may become too cumbersome or tight when worn. Luckily, the team at Forsythe Jewelers can easily adjust your rings, necklaces, and broaches to ensure they fit as intended while still retaining their original beauty and value. Whether your wedding ring is feeling too tight or you'd like a family heirloom adjusted so a loved one can wear it, we'll ensure the resizing is done with the utmost care and skill.Give new life to your favorite jewelry pieces by having them resized at Forsythe Jewelers today.
Your family's keepsakes have been passed down through the generations and entrusted to you, so how do you keep them protected from age, decay, and damage? At Forsythe Jewelers, we provide expert jewelry restorations that will ensure your estate jewelry's most beautiful features are preserved while repairing any damage that may have taken place to them over the years.
Reviews (9)
Jenna Dosch
May 19, 2022
My wife and I were vacationing in Hilton Head this past week and stopped in. My wife wanted to buy me a gift to celebrate my recent job (The bway tour of Frozen). I had a bit of a a hard time deciding, but Keith stayed with us the whole time, offering suggestions and being incredibly patient and kind. We ended up with a gorgeous David Yurman necklace that I am absolutely in love with. Thank you Forsythe Jewelers, and thank you so much Keith for your wonderful and attentive service, we look forward to seeing you the next time we visit!
Julia Pikula
Sep 13, 2021
My daughter recently got married and was given a gift from Forsythe Jewelers. The item was not one on her registry. I called to exchange for an item on her registry. We live out of state. We were told we could exchange the item but it would be a $35 shipping charge to ship the new item. If we chose not to ship the item we could take a store credit.
Obviously that did not make sense because we live out of state. The sales clerk suggested we regift the item. Which I thought was distasteful. Everyone does not regift wedding gifts. No one I know charges $35 to ship an item, especially a small kitchen item that is not breakable. My experience with this company is less than satisfactory. Honestly I am shocked that their policies do not better accommodate out of town customers. Due to their location on Hilton Head Island I would think they highly depend on tourist purchases.
Obviously that did not make sense because we live out of state. The sales clerk suggested we regift the item. Which I thought was distasteful. Everyone does not regift wedding gifts. No one I know charges $35 to ship an item, especially a small kitchen item that is not breakable. My experience with this company is less than satisfactory. Honestly I am shocked that their policies do not better accommodate out of town customers. Due to their location on Hilton Head Island I would think they highly depend on tourist purchases.
Linda Moloney
Jul 22, 2021
Kate Hausmann
May 26, 2021
My family and I have been coming to Forsythe Jewelers for our jewelry needs for a decade or more. The staff is always so warm and welcome. They will pull different pieces and keep it on a list for you or a loved one to purchase at a later date. We have run into one issue in the past and they made sure to communicate the game plan with us and made us feel really special. We are lucky to have Forsythe Jewelers in our community and network!
Michelle Cormeny
Apr 07, 2021
Scott Regan
Feb 06, 2020
Megan Stevenson
Feb 14, 2019
Michael Klapper
Apr 17, 2018
Paige Romanowski
Apr 28, 2017
We love visiting and shopping with our friends at Forsythe Jewelers. They have a gorgeous selection of designer jewelry in every price range. Laurie takes wonderful care of us when we are in town and even stocks my husbands favorite beer to sip on while we shop! Treat yourself to Forsythe Jewelers, it's worth it!
