Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Bellestar Jewelry What People Are Saying I got my fianc's engagement ring from Bellestar. Paul made a process that I was very nervous about an easy one to cope with. His knowledge of diamonds and his understanding my budget made it very easy to work with him. My fianc still gets compliments- almost daily on the beauty and sparkle of the ring.
Reviews (9)
Write a Review
Tommy Countie
Jan 19, 2022
I wanted to thank Paul for his help when it was time to make the decision to buy a engagement ring I was nervous to say the least but Paul made me so comfortable and explained to me what was a appropriate price to pay to both make may girl happy but still have lunch money left in my pocket I still was nervous if she would like it or not but at the end he made or helped me make the best decision and she is thrilled with the ring and not a day goes by that she doesn't get a compliment on her ring at work at the hospital im so happy I went with Paul at Bellestars jewelers
Heidi Conway
Jun 06, 2021
Paul has been wonderful helping us with my mother jewelry. Professional, trustworthy and very patient. He also made a ring for me a while back, his craftsmanship is fabulous and his attention to detail is what makes Paul and Bellestar so fabulous!
Marissa Piatelli
May 06, 2021
Paul and his team are truly the best in the business. They make you feel comfortable and listen and create exactly what you're looking for. I highly recommend Paul and the team at Bellestar Jewelry. I wouldn't do business anywhere else!
Lee Fraser
Apr 10, 2021
Paul does not just give excellent customer service, but he treated us with kindness and compassion! Thank you for your help yesterday and today, Paul - my father and I will pay it forward! Also, the selection of jewelry is spectacular! I have never seen black pearls anywhere else!
Deneen Caprio
Mar 20, 2021
From the moment you walk into Bellestar you will feel welcome, and you will leave as Paul's friend He is honest, knowledgeable and an all around great guy My family has done business with him for over a decade. Paul has made custom jewelry for me, once designing a tennis bracelet, that I rarely wore into a gorgeous ring that I have received many compliments on.

On a recent visit, a young man came in looking to purchase an engagement ring. I overheard him say that he wasn't sure of how to make this important purchase or how much he was "supposed" to spend. Without hesitation Paul, in a fatherlike voice exclaimed "You are supposed to spend what you can afford and what you are comfortable with ". That folks, is what you call integrity. I honestly believe that in a different jewelry store, that young man would have ended up in over his head I refer everyone to Bellestar!
Darlene Kelliher
Feb 07, 2021
Bellestar Jewelry is the only place I will purchase jewelry. Mr. Murphy is so very patient, knowledgeable, and helpful. He is also very skilled at repair and appraisal. Going back soon for another beautiful gift!
Jamie-Lynn Lambert
Jan 13, 2021
We had the BEST experience at Bellestar Jewelry! Not only did Paul help my fiance pick out my engagement ring (when I had no idea what I even wanted) he also made us feel like we were the only couple in the store! He also helped us with our wedding bands and had them beautifully engraved with our initials and wedding date. He is knowledgeable, funny, and makes the experience fun and SO exciting! Couldn't recommend Bellestar more for all your jewelry needs!
Barbara Hall
Nov 29, 2020
The staff of Bellestarjewelry go out of their way to suggest items that you are looking for! They will order anything that you are looking for, and also do special orders from designs you want! Highly recommend Paul and his team! Always helpful from repairs to design!
Jan Bruno
Nov 21, 2020
Paul is amazing! He has been our go to jeweler since we got married in 1998. Top notch service and beautiful jewelry.