Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Jeff Karl Jewelers is located on historic Route 66 in the charming downtown district of Flagstaff, Arizona, a destination known for its unique and locally owned galleries, shops and restaurants. In addition, Jeff Karl Jewelers has the added convenience of ample parking directly in front of the store. With the laid-back elegance of a comfortable living space, Jeff Karl Jewelers, for over 11 years, has offered a combination of personalized attention to customers' concerns and a captivating variety of handcrafted fine designer jewelry.
Reviews (24)
Write a Review
Anthony Maestas
Jun 23, 2022
Went in here to get some earrings switched over to earcuffs, they did a good job with them and did it for a good price.
Stephen Brooks
Jun 15, 2022
They came in very clutch same day called to quickly adjust my fiancees ring and they did it very quickly and professionally! Save our road trip :
Darryl S.
Dec 17, 2021
Outstanding Jewery store with a very quant local Flagstaff atmosphere! I have to say the owner (Jeff) and his staff are extremely nice and pleasant. I called Jeff on Veterans Day and asked him if he could polish my watch as it had some surface scratches on it. He informed me he would be very happy to do it for me and that there was no charge since I was a veteran, which was very nice. Jeff, also asked me if I could leave the watch so that he would have time to do it properly, which I did. I picked up the watch the next business day and it looked amazing! Thank you, Jeff and the pleasant staff! Darryl.
Sydney Abbott
Nov 30, 2021
Jeff Karl is amazing! We stopped in while on a road trip having decided to get engaged and we were looking for a specific style of ring which Julia, the kind person helping us, was able to make happen! Her and Jeff came up with this ring in 24 hours- exactly what I wanted and better than I imagined! And totally within our budget. I couldn't be happier with the customer service and the product we received. It'll be a lifelong treasure Thanks again!
G. L.
Sep 26, 2021
My wife and I stayed for a few nights in Flagstaff for our 40th Anniversary. We went to Jeff Karl Jewelers to find ruby jewelry. We were met by two very nice ladies who helped us find a pair of ear rings and a diamond- ruby ring. We liked them and my wife was very happy for the deal they made for us. The ring needed to be sized and they did it overnight for us as we were leaving he next day. We were so very happy that they took care of us. Thanks again for the good service we received.
Michael M.
Aug 02, 2021
Great service, great prices. This man is the most knowledgeable jewelry person I've ever dealt with. You would be making a mistake if you don't try him first.
Heather Heslop
Jul 19, 2021
I was very happy with these guys. I brought my wedding ring in for a quote to get a small stone in my ring replaced and they recommended re-capping the prongs on the big stone as well. They did all this for $60. I was expecting it to be much more based on my internet search. They were a day late getting finished but it was well worth it. My ring came back good as new and soooo shiny! Great people to work with. Would absolutely go back. Highly recommend.
Casey O'Leary
Feb 06, 2021
Jeff was very knowledgeable and easy to work with. I wanted to repurpose the gold from an old family heirloom into my wedding band. Jeff understood what I wanted and delivered exactly what I asked for. In fact, his work was so nice that we had Jeff craft a matching band for my wife.
Lorne C.
Jul 10, 2020
Wow! I can't begin to express how impressed I am with this store. From the customer service, to the repair, and finally the price. Julia was very pleasant and nice, as she helped to make my wife a very happy person on her birthday. My wife is very sick and while in the hospital she lost a stone on her wedding ring. With very short notice (same day) Jeff repaired her ring and it was absolutely beautiful. I will always think of them first for any of my jewelry related business and highly recommend them to all. Thank you so much!
Brian Mcdonald
Apr 04, 2020
I have been lucky to say i have been buying jewelry and getting repairs done from Jeff for over 15 years. His craftsmanship is top notch and every custom piece we have done with him surpasses our expectations. You get local hometown customer service that is better than any other jeweler I have dealt with. Thank you hands down 5 stars
Bri Bardo
Mar 20, 2020
I would recommend Jeff and his entire team to my close friends and family. let alone strangers. Jeff fall team exceeded my expectations. I walked into the Jew let's just to look as we were in the market for a new wedding set. The staff Was well versed and educated on their selection as well as what they could bring into the store. I immediately fell in love with an engagement ring but wass unsure as I wanted to see another style I was interested in. Jeff's team ordered me the other style just so I could see and confirm what I loved and wanted.

Then I was able to choose the exact diamond for my engagement ring at a very reasonable price. Finally, Jeff was able to help me meet my budget for the ring. This entire experience was a dream and I have the ring I will cherish forever and am truly grateful for the ring and experience I have had at Jeff Karl Jewelers.
Sandy Corder Matlock
Feb 03, 2020
Outstanding artistry and service! Jeff designed my wedding ring to fit perfectly with my 1910 Edwardian engagement ring. He wasn't exactly what we wanted and offered suggestions. Couldn't be happier!
Lauren K.
Dec 27, 2019
Shayna was the absolute best with helping me pick out a promise ring for my boyfriend. She was so friendly. My order came in the next day. Totally prefer this place over companies like Kay or Jared.
Sarah F.
Sep 08, 2019
My fiance had a custom ring designed for me at Jeff Karl. He brought family diamonds in gold to be made into the ring of my dreams and Jeff did not disappoint. This ring was such a huge part of one of the best days of my life and I am so happy my fiance went to Jeff Karl to make this happen. Since getting engaged, we have gone back to have my fiance's wedding band made and I have had my ring cleaned a couple of times. Jeff is incredibly knowledgeable and kind every time we visit. I will forever trust Jeff Karl with all of my jewelry needs!
Dan R.
May 23, 2019
I've been very happy with my purchases and repairs here. I've dealt with the owner and a few of the staff and all my experiences have been very good.
Trista Custer
Jan 24, 2018
Jeff Karl does wonderful work at a fair and honest price. I feel like he treats each piece of jewelry like the customer it belongs to, kind, respectful, and wanting it to last forever. Although we did not purchase my wedding ring from this store, he's taken great care and pride in cleaning and repairing it in the 7+ years I've had it. He is also the only jeweler I trust to appraise it for our insurance coverage! I look forward to working with him for many years to come!
Sarah D.
Jan 19, 2018
If you are not sure about doing business here, let me tell you to GO! I don't normally leave a review. If I do, my reviews are few and far between and I've been thoroughly impressed with my experiences. This is actually my 2nd review (a first for me) for this jeweler. Their fair services, prices and expertise go far beyond my knowledge and expectations.

I am 3rd generation Flag and have never presumed I could benefit from that relationship to town. All I have to say, to wrap up my ramble is. GO, and experience for yourself! A pic to display their creativity, craftsmanship (and all else you can't see) is included! #BEEYOUTEEFUL I love thumb hole shirts, lol. The Karl's rock #karljewelers #shoplocal #ilove
David G.
Aug 31, 2017
Took wives wedding set in to resize, they found some damage and I ask Jeff about completing set, he did great work and have me a more than fair price. Would gladly use this shop for all my needs in jewelry.
Michael W.
Aug 23, 2017
Had my watch sized here. They were very nice and professional, they got it sized right and charged me fairly.
Kim M.
Oct 07, 2016
I was visiting my in laws in Flagstaff and broke a gold chain. Took it to Jeff Karl and they were able to fix the fine chain - it looks brand new! No visible signs of repair, they did a great job. I told them I needed to have the fix done within three days when I leave Flagstaff and they fixed it in a couple of hours for only $25. This place deserves five stars.
Cara L.
Mar 11, 2016
My husband and I both did our wedding rings through Jeff Karl and he did them very quickly and they are absolutely gorgeous original, unique pieces! I have never seen anything like my wedding ring anywhere and I love how willing Jeff was to make it. He also backs up his craft very well with cleanings, reparations, and anything else necessary!
Michelle F.
Sep 05, 2014
My husband got my engagement ring from Jeff and I have to it's such a gorgeous ring and it's to the T exactly what I wanted (so kudos to my husband and to Jeff) but I have to say I am so overly impressed with the service I got when I just went to get the ring sized as wells as when we got both of out wedding bands! Jeff and all the the associates there genuinely care about their customers and you can just tell they all enjoy their jobs! Such a better experience compared to a corporate store! We were recommended to go here from a friend and we from here on always recommend Jeff to anyone!
Valerie P.
Jul 01, 2012
Great people and a great business! I had a watch sized and my wedding ring sized. The lady at the desk was friendly and helpful. Jeff was friendly and went over the process he used to take the links off my watch just so I would know for the future. I only left my ring with them for a week or so, and the results were beautiful and affordable. I will definitely return if I need something else done to my jewelry.
Andee B.
Nov 20, 2010
Let's just say we live in San Diego and will only go to Jeff for our jewelry needs! The care they give you is unlike any other jeweler. I have an engagement ring, wedding band, and anniversary band from Jeff Karl Jewelers. After about five years I needed them to be re-sized up a half size, soldered, and rhodium plated (which you need to do every few years with white gold).

I expected to pay a pretty penny for all of this. Nope, I only paid for shipping! I love the service, they will never take advantage of you, and the quality of the jewelery is only the best. Again, we will always shop at Jeff Karl Jewelers!