Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
All That Glitters All that Glitters has been the premier jewelry store in Old Colorado City. Known for the quality and craftsmanship of its pieces, All that Glitters specializes in custom jewelry design, accurate appraisals, jewelry repairs, special orders, layaways and creative remountings. Our Staff includes international and national award winning designers and goldsmiths!
Follow us
Reviews (17)
Write a Review
Joe Flanary
Jun 19, 2022
Great folks, custom orders and very fair pricing. Extremely helpful. Made us a great quote on a custom piece of jewelry.
Jeremy Sanders
May 13, 2022
They did a fantastic job helping me design and order my fiance's engagement ring. It looks absolutely great, and she loved it! Definitely recommend All That Glitters, they are a great small business that does quality work!
Andrea Green
May 12, 2022
This is the only store I will use to get my jewelry repaired. Excellent customer service and fair prices.
Megan Morris
May 10, 2022
They did a beautiful job repairing the broken prong on my wedding ring. The entire staff is wonderful to work with. I will definitely be using them for any future needs!
Deb Riekeman
Mar 26, 2022
I was impressed with a jewelry store with an owner who is not only knowledgeable but very fair about repairs. I highly recommend them.
Ryan Cooper
Dec 11, 2021
I've been to All That Glitters twice and Carol has taken care of me both times. She is very friendly and knowledgeable and I'd highly recommend anyone in Colorado Springs to check out All That Glitters.
Savannah Mann
Nov 28, 2021
They soldered my ring, fixed a few prongs, and cleaned it so well. Even amidst them moving buildings it only took a few weeks. Extremely knowledgable, professional, helpful, and kind. I will definitely be back!
Lucky Stoller
Oct 31, 2021
Lovely people, beautiful merchandise and very skilled design and repairs. All That Glitters is our only family jeweler now for lovely tokens that mark our important occasions.
Kate R.
Aug 17, 2021
I came in with a tricky repair on a tiara and they did it quickly and for a great price. I completely trust the integrity of this store and will be back! Thank you for being so welcoming to a new member of the community!
Joe Nellesen
May 15, 2021
My wife's odd unique vintage wedding ring had been damaged and other jewelry places told me it was a lost cause and could not be fixed. All That Glitter is awesome. They fixed it up with a creative idea and made the ring more sturdy then it's ever been. It looks amazing! I surprised my wife and she was shocked how they got it fixed and made it look so nice. Also, the price was more than reasonable. I expected a higher price, but they were more than fair. Highly recommend these guys for jewelry repair. Thanks again Joe
Linda Campos
Apr 27, 2021
My experience was absolutely perfect. The staff is so kind and very polite and understands what a costumer wants and meets the expectations to every little detail. I would highly recommend going to this location for custom jewelry, or any other service. The are amazing. Thank you for fixing my weeding rings and making them new after 16 years.
Red
Jul 09, 2020
Could not be happier with the service I received! I had several repairs on rings and bracelets done as well as a custom setting for an amethyst ring that had belonged to my Grandmother. Steve took the time to understand what type of setting I was looking for and what style of ring I preferred. He then presented me with 3 beautiful options. When I chose one and had a modification suggestion he was very accommodating and helped me to decide on what other stones to include in the new setting. The new ring is absolutely STUNNING! Everyone at All That Glitters are the nicest people you could meet. I will definitely be back for another custom piece!
Theresa G.
Dec 14, 2019
All That Glitters made my jewelry dreams come true. I brought them components of a ring that only existed in my mind, and they returned an engagement ring beyond our expectations, and ahead of schedule as well! We will always appreciate the kind, professional service we received at All That Glitters, and would never hesitate to recommend them.
Andrea J.
Aug 15, 2019
I never go anywhere else for my jewelry needs! My diamond was loose again and they tightened it up and made it sparkle like new! The staff are always so friendly, also! I highly recommend this business!
Cathy P.
Dec 14, 2018
This is the best jewelry store in Colorado Springs, perhaps the State! We have bought jewelry from them for decades. They sell the most unique, gorgeous and quality fine jewelry you'll ever find at very reasonable prices. And if they don't have what you like they'll custom make it. They have staff that have been with them for years and years which speaks to the kind of company they are.

No matter how much time between our visits, they remember our names and the piece we bought! Even among the cases and cases of beautiful jewelry the staff is not intimidating or superior. They are approachable and friendly and treated my simple sterling silver necklace that I brought in for repair with the same respect and care of a thousand dollar piece. Don't go anywhere else. When you're talking about such a precious and personal item like your jewelry, you need someone you can trust and that's All That Glitters.
Amy C.
Nov 18, 2018
My husband and I had my wedding ring and band custom made and they did an amazing job and affordable! Now I have a one of a kind piece and friends for life! They hand sketched and created my dream ring!
Kathleen Allred
Sep 17, 2016
I've been going to this shop for 10 years now and absolutely love it. I knew I'd find my engagement and wedding ring there, and did in their estate section (though they have amazing new engagement rings from Gabriel & Co). They have so many unique pieces, and almost all of my favorite pieces I own are from this store. See a few below in the pic! The staff is attentive, kind, and helpful. If you've never been in this shop before, it's definitely worth checking out!