Blue Marlin Jewelry

Let's talk about integrity. Blue Marlin Jewelry was recommended as a reliable place to repair two bracelets that were extremely important to me - and they vastly exceeded my expectations. I am so impressed with their knowledge and experience - aside from advising me on the best way to implement the repair, they actually took the time to explain the process, and options, to improve the durability and appearance of my jewelry.

I'm floored by their attention to detail and extraordinary craftsmanship. They won a customer for life with their kindness and commanding knowledge of making, repairing, and purveying premium and iconic jewelry. By the way, their collection of nautical creations is extraordinary. A must see.

We stopped in to Blue Marlin as mere tourists just killing time. We received the kindest attention from Penny. She patiently guided us through their exquisite selections while we floundered (no pun intended) to make a decision. We left thrilled and excited at finding our future wedding bands. Our deepest thanks as we know what we purchased will shine brilliantly in our hearts.

25 years ago I purchased a ring from Blue Marlin Jewelry. An opal cracked this year. I called and was thrilled that Armando was still at the store. Penny was a huge help with setting up the repair of my ring. A beautiful experience, once again.

I've been married for 46 years, and lost the diamond from my engagement ring. This jewelry store not only replaced it, but made rhe experience very special! I highly recommend this store!

I haven't received my item yet but Blue Marlin was engaged from the moment I ordered. I have a quick story.many years ago I managed a high volume tourist restaurant and during a particularly rough time in my life in addition to a chaotic day, I discovered a little Blue Marlin gift bag, with a card addressed "for you", although it was not specifically for me the card was a kind and thoughtful expression to whomever discovered this bag with a shiny jewelry bobble in there.

I hope that many more of your gifts found there way to the right person's at just the right time! Your a stellar part of our community and from me personally. I'm grateful you are part of our keys community, you are wonderful owners, managers, and staff!

From the minute you walk through the door, it speaks of class and world-class service. The selection is vast! Penny, Shannon, Corrine and the new associate were very welcoming and pleasant. I had the opportunity to meet Armando, the owner who was quite gracious and appreciative of the business. I left some watches for battery replacements and the receipt shows photos of your item left for repair, which impressed me.

Who customizes classy receipts? They also displayed some unique phone holders with fish, turtles, flamingos, etc. and lots of bling! Check it out! You will not be disappointed.

They are the best! I Was having my rings cleaned and Armando noticed the prongs were loose on my diamond. And my wedding band had a crack in it. I got both back. They look brand new after 41 years! The staff at Blue Marlin are so helpful and knowledgeable. Thank you so much Blue Marlin!

A friend highly recommended Blue Marlin Jewelry for some repairs. Repairs were expertly done while we waited! We will definitely be back and highly recommend! Well worth the drive from Big Pine! Thank you!

These people are among my true friends here in islamorada and have been very kind to me and if. You want to buy a beautiful piece of jewelry as a memento of the beautiful place i have lived in please come in and visit with Armando and his wonderful staff

Patient. Knowledgeable. No pressure. And the selection - stunning. Blue Marlin is our family jeweler, for new purchases, repairs, and restoration/enhancement of family pieces we've owned for decades. Even when what we seek is "low dollar" compared to what's under the glass, the service is as stellar as if we were buying the whole family matching Rolexes. Besides their professional storefront, the business is hands-on for nourishing and supporting the well being of the community.

When you walk in, it feels like you're with family! I'm from out of town and recently engaged here in Islamorada! My ring was a size too big and felt funny being so loose on my ring finger. We came in for an insert to help the ring fit properly until we are able to get home to our jeweler. Not only was the whole staff friendly and celebrated our recent engagement with us, but they quickly sized my finger and gave us the insert on the house!

As funny as it may be, my fiance would have paid anything for that insert. This, all for a ring that was not purchased from Blue Marlin. Their actions speak volumes to the way they do business. I have felt uneasy going into some jewelry stores, but Blue Marlin Jewelry is not one of those places. I know that when we come back to Islamorada, we can walk into Blue Marlin Jewelry and be treated like family.

If you are in the Keys, Blue Marlin Jewelry is the only place to shop for unique jewelry. Great service and a wonderful selection.

The jewlers there are amazing! Penny helped me out with every step and got a beautiful piece of jewelry that I've never seen before. I'm so excited to get it!

A truly delightful shopping experience. I worked with Penny on this purchase but all the store personnel are superb, knowledgeable, and most accommodating to special requests or requirements. And it is a really beautiful store on top of it all.

The true gems at this jewelry store is the staff, so friendly, helpful and patient, thank you.

We always make a point to stop here while we are visiting the keys. They have a great selection of nautical jewelry and the ladies always do their best to help find the perfect pieces. The owner even goes out of his way to polish our past purchases when we come in which makes us feel like we are valued. Highly recommend if you're in Islamorada on passing through.

We stop in every year while in the Keys on vacation. The sales people are all very kind and helpful. Always willing to spend as much time with each customer as needed. They even make wish lists and send all information to you in an email for later purchases! Always a pleasure purchasing from Blue Marlin Jewelry.

Very nice jewelry. Many unusual pieces mostly with a nautical theme. Sales person very helpful and friendly.

This is the only place to go for your jewelry repair! I'd lost a ruby from my favorite 20 yr old bracelet. Aimee found a natural stone to match the other stones within my tight budget. Jason had the stone set, prongs repaired and bracelet polished for wearing inside of an hour of my approving the quote to do the work. I was in and out wearing my bracelet in under 24 hours. Caring. Quick. Meticulous. High Quality. Reasonable Price. Beautiful Workmanship.

Beautiful jewelry, however what really shines are the owner & staff. Friendly & very helpful.

The Blue Marlin team is always kind, helpful and deliver some of our most cherished pieces! They offer a unique selection of top designers. It's a great way to keep a piece of the Keys with you wherever you are!

So many unusual pieces, this is a one of a kind jewelry shop.

Customer service excellence, quality one of a kind pieces, Armando is a true community oriented business owner. Great place to go for the perfect gift or just a wonderful gift for yourself.

Amazing customer service and attention to detail. thank you Armando

Marina is the best. Always does an excellent job when I order. Beautiful jewelry